Cleveland Guardians outfielder Steven Kwan has established himself as one of the best contact hitters and defensive players in Major League Baseball today. Known for his relentless hustle, sharp fundamentals, and elite outfield defense, it’s no surprise that his list of top five MLB players of all time reflects similar traits.
During an interview on the No Agenda podcast on Wednesday, Kwan revealed his selections, putting a heavy emphasis on players who embodied hard work, defensive excellence, and smart baseball rather than just raw power. The list features names that might not always be in the usual GOAT conversations, but for Kwan, they represent the kind of players he aspires to be.
1. Ichiro Suzuki – The Epitome of Consistency and Excellence
If there is any player who serves as the perfect blueprint for Kwan’s playing style, it’s Ichiro Suzuki. The former Seattle Mariners legend revolutionized hitting in MLB, breaking records and redefining how contact hitters could dominate the game.
“Ichiro—number one for sure,” Kwan stated (46:12 onwards in the podcast). “I’m probably missing some, but those are the ones that jump to the top of my mind right now. Ichiro.”
Suzuki’s career accolades speak for themselves:
- AL MVP (2001) and Rookie of the Year in the same season
- 10-time All-Star
- 10 Gold Glove Awards
- 262 hits in a single season (MLB record)
- 3,089 career MLB hits
Ichiro’s unique batting approach, impeccable defense, and base-running prowess set him apart as one of the greatest to ever play the game. Kwan, being a left-handed contact hitter with similar size and speed, naturally admires the Japanese icon.
2. Ender Inciarte – A Defensive Wizard in the Outfield
Kwan’s second pick was an unexpected yet insightful selection: Ender Inciarte. The former Gold Glove-winning outfielder played for the Arizona Diamondbacks and Atlanta Braves, making a name for himself with outstanding defensive ability and agility.
“My first one’s going to be Ender Inciarte. What got me was seeing him — I think he’s Venezuelan — doing these outfield drills on the beach, working in the sand, just getting after it,” Kwan explained.
Inciarte’s ability to track down fly balls, make acrobatic catches, and contribute as a reliable contact hitter made him an underrated force in the MLB.
Kwan also related to Inciarte due to their similar stature:
“I think he was like 5’10”, maybe 5’11”, kind of a shorter guy like me. He’s still taller, but just seeing him make these all-out plays was crazy.”
3. Cole Calhoun – Hustle, Heart, and Spectacular Defense
Next on Kwan’s list was Cole Calhoun, a former teammate and one of the grittiest players in baseball. Known for his all-out playing style, Calhoun’s defensive efforts in right field, combined with his ability to hit for power, made him an exciting player to watch.
“That Superman dive where he just almost belly flops hard,” Kwan reminisced. “I got to see that in person, and it was a full-circle moment for me. That was so cool. He’s a baller, plays the game the right way — he’s got to be up there.”
Calhoun’s Gold Glove-winning defense and infectious energy resonated deeply with Kwan, proving that effort and determination can have just as much of an impact as raw talent.
4. Travis Shaw – The Underrated Powerhouse
While Travis Shaw may not be a household name among baseball legends, Kwan had high praise for the former MLB infielder. Shaw, nicknamed “The Mayor of Ding Dong City,” was known for his power at the plate and ability to come through in clutch moments.
“Travis Shaw — yes, sir, was a dog,” Kwan said, showing admiration for the slugger’s mentality and performance on the field.
Shaw played for the Milwaukee Brewers and Boston Red Sox, delivering key hits and earning respect as a hard-nosed competitor. Although not as decorated as others on this list, his work ethic and determination left a lasting impression on Kwan.
5. Buster Posey – The Ultimate Leader and Champion
The final player on Kwan’s list was a name synonymous with winning and excellence—Buster Posey. The former San Francisco Giants catcher was not only a seven-time All-Star but also a three-time World Series champion and NL MVP in 2012.
“Buster Posey did everything for the Bay, and now he’s an owner over there. So, you know, if he ever wants to finesse my way over there, I’d love to. That’d be amazing,” Kwan joked.
Posey was one of the best catchers of his generation, excelling both offensively and defensively. His leadership behind the plate and clutch hitting were instrumental in the Giants’ three championships (2010, 2012, 2014), and his impact on the game is undeniable.
A Unique Perspective on Greatness
Steven Kwan’s top five MLB players of all time provide insight into his personal approach to the game. Rather than selecting power hitters or historically dominant figures like Babe Ruth or Barry Bonds, Kwan focused on players known for their hustle, defense, and fundamentals—qualities that define his own game.
His admiration for Ichiro Suzuki makes perfect sense given his playstyle, while his picks of Inciarte, Calhoun, Shaw, and Posey highlight his respect for gritty, team-oriented players who maximize their potential.
While these names might not appear on everyone’s “Greatest of All Time” lists, they represent the essence of baseball that Kwan values most—hard work, elite defense, and a passion for the game.
